The blog option I chose was option 1. The connection between
the article above and the baseball mitt in The Catcher in the Rye was that they
were both very small items and things, the baseball mitt in Catcher in the Rye
and the rattle in the article above. But they both ended up showing a much
deeper meaning in the reading. The baseball mitt was Holden’s brother’s mitt
who died, so the baseball mitt means a lot to Holden and is not just a glove,
it is something that will stay with Holden for forever to remember his brother.
The rattling noise in the other passage shows that the rattling noise that
cannot be fixed provides a much deeper meaning in life with things people might
be going through in their life that just cannot be fixed. Like maybe losing a brother just like Holden
did. The rattling noise is such a simple problem but the writer uses that
problem to create much deeper meanings and much deeper problems and pushes the writing
forward by saying things like: “The
cancer you survived, but leaves you feeling unsettled.” “Your rattle.” This
article is really about hard, deep problems that you just cannot overcome or
cannot fix. The second half of this article could definitely apply to Holden
because the baseball mitt is the rattle and Holden’s brother dying is the much
deeper, more complex problem that can be taken from such a smaller item or
smaller problem. This is Holden’s “rattle.”
I appreciate your response because it gives a very clear explanation of what the rattle from the the article means. Also, it made a strong connection between Holden and the article.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your blog post because it explains the use of symbolism in this novel and its connection to the article. A piece of evidence that could strengthen your response from the book is, "Old Allie's baseball mitt. I happened to have it, in y suit case, so I got it out and copied down the poems that were written on it." This quote further explains how he keeps Allie's baseball mitt with him even though it reminds him of her death. Do you think that Holden has any other "rattles" in the book?
ReplyDelete